[NEW] Notice and Proposal: Mine Reserve Completion and CTSI MinterRole Renunciation

Part 1 - Notice

Mine Reserve: Completion of Staking Rewards in 2027

Proposer: Cartesi Foundation

About this notice: Mine Reserve-funded staking rewards are projected to end around July 2027. This post explains the expected timing and implications for stakers. A separate MinterRole proposal invites community discussion on permanently removing minting authority under the existing CTSI token contract.

Completion of the Mine Reserve

The Mine Reserve was established as a finite allocation of CTSI to fund staking rewards through the Noether proof-of-stake system. The deployed reward mechanism distributes a fixed amount per produced block until the allocated funds are exhausted.

As of October 27, 2026, approximately 29,009,017 CTSI remain in the Mine Reserve, with recent distributions averaging approximately 3.2 million CTSI per month.

At that rate, Mine Reserve-funded staking rewards are projected to end in 9-10 months, around July 2027. The timing may vary depending on the pace of block production.

The remaining reserve and its distributions can be monitored onchain through the DelayedWithdraw, Reserve Mine Wallet, and RewardManager contracts.

Background

Noether was originally conceived as a data availability network secured by CTSI staking. As specialized data availability solutions matured, Cartesi focused exclusively on verifiable execution and sought integration with existing solutions rather than developing its own data availability network.

The Foundation consequently discontinued funding Noether’s development toward that original purpose, as discussed in Moving on from Noether as a data availability network. The previously proposed CTSI Macroeconomy was not implemented and is no longer being pursued.

Noether’s proof-of-stake system has nevertheless remained operational, providing staking rewards and a basis for governance voting power. It does not secure Cartesi Rollups’ execution.

What this means for stakers

The completion of Mine Reserve rewards does not alter staked balances or the existing ability to stake, unstake, and withdraw CTSI. No action is required solely because rewards are ending. Delegators can withdraw even if their pool’s node is no longer running, but may need to initiate pool rebalancing themselves.

The end of Mine Reserve-funded rewards does not itself change the existing governance voting configuration. Under the current voting configuration, voting power is derived from CTSI delegated to eligible staking pools.

Cartesi’s direction

Cartesi’s current strategy focuses on putting its verifiable execution technology to work under real commercial conditions. The Foundation is concentrating its engineering and business development efforts on supporting Knoss, an independent derivatives exchange being built on Cartesi Rollups, while advancing the reliability, verification, and security of the underlying infrastructure.

Working closely with a commercial application allows practical requirements to inform infrastructure development. Cartesi remains open source and general purpose, so improvements developed through this work remain available to other applications.

Further details are available in The Next Stage for Cartesi.

This notice is informational and does not require a governance vote.

Part 2 - Proposal

Permanently Renounce the CTSI MinterRole

Proposer: Cartesi Foundation

About this proposal: The Foundation proposes permanently removing minting authority under the existing CTSI token contract. The proposal is open for 21 days of community discussion before a governance vote. Information about the completion of Mine Reserve-funded staking rewards is provided in a separate notice.

Proposal and rationale

The Cartesi Foundation proposes permanently renouncing the remaining MinterRole permissions on the existing CTSI token contract.

The original CTSI Macroeconomy contemplated creating additional CTSI through a broader staking incentive mechanism. This mechanism was not implemented and, following Cartesi’s focus on verifiable execution, is no longer being pursued.

With no plans to implement the originally proposed issuance mechanism, the Foundation considers it appropriate to permanently remove the ability to mint additional CTSI under the existing token contract. This would formally close an unused feature no longer required by Cartesi’s technical and economic arrangements and permanently fix the total supply under the existing token contract at 1 billion CTSI.

Renouncing all remaining minting permissions would permanently remove the privileged authority to issue additional CTSI or appoint new minters under the existing contract, also eliminating any related security vulnerabilities.

What changes?

The sole account holding the MinterRole is:

0x4B0B3C9506d5008FcCfb458361E06d28d4d3BCAD

Once every account holding the MinterRole has renounced it, no further CTSI can be minted under the existing token contract. This change is irreversible.

The proposal does not alter CTSI balances, staking or withdrawal operations, governance voting rules, or any existing ecosystem incentive arrangement. Following renunciation, any future CTSI-funded initiatives would need to use tokens from the existing supply.

Community consultation and vote

As this change is irreversible, the proposal will remain open for public discussion for 21 calendar days from publication.

Following consultation, a governance vote will ask:

Do you support permanently renouncing the MinterRole on the existing CTSI token contract?

  • For: Support permanent renunciation.

  • Against: Do not support permanent renunciation.

Implementation and verification

If approved, the Foundation will arrange for the renunciation and publish the transaction records together with onchain verification that no accounts retain the MinterRole.

If not approved, the Foundation will not proceed under this proposal.

6 Likes

Makes a lot of sense to remove staking, since it indeed isn’t contributing to anything meaningful

1 Like

FOR

If we don’t have any good reason for operational capabilities of Cartesi, of course I support renounciation of minter role. This was at the beginning, one of the main reasons(FIXED SUPPLY and others)I have been following and supporting this lovely project.

Thanks all the professionals involved. :heart:

1 Like

As a CTSI holder, I support permanently renouncing the MinterRole on the existing CTSI token contract.

The original issuance mechanism was never implemented and is no longer being pursued, so keeping this minting authority serves no clear purpose while leaving a security risk in place. Renouncing it permanently fixes the total supply at 1 billion CTSI and gives holders clearer, more predictable token economics.

I also welcome that this proposal does not change CTSI balances, staking or withdrawal operations, or governance voting rules. Future CTSI-funded initiatives can and should be funded from the existing supply.

After approval, I hope the Foundation will publish the renunciation transaction records together with clear on-chain verification that no account retains the MinterRole, so the community can confirm this change independently.

1 Like

Supporting the proposal !

Fixing $CTSI supply for good and being clear about the staking rewards ending soon shows the team is thinking long-term

1 Like

I support permanently renouncing the CTSI MinterRole. Since the previously proposed issuance mechanism is no longer being pursued, fixing the total supply at 1 billion CTSI would provide greater certainty for holders while removing an unnecessary privileged authority and its associated security risks.

저는 CTSI의 MinterRole을 영구적으로 포기하는 방안에 찬성합니다. 기존에 제안됐던 추가 발행 메커니즘을 더 이상 추진하지 않는 만큼, CTSI의 총공급량을 10억 개로 확정하면 보유자들에게 더 높은 예측 가능성을 제공할 수 있다고 생각합니다. 또한 불필요해진 특수 권한과 그에 따른 보안 위험까지 제거할 수 있다는 점에서도 긍정적입니다.

1 Like

I just went through it now and I actually find it hard to find a middle ground on whether to not to to continue with the rewards.

here’s my two cents on the issue.

- Lets say someone has around 1 - 25M $CTSI tokens and just wants to HODL because he / she believes in the cartesi goal and ofcourse wants it to gain traction in the long run meaning an increase in price for that person.

Just holding the tokens in your wallet will feel dormant and we humans are greedy, we always want to earn, so in this scenario, keeping the staking rewards make sense so that people can earn yield from their balances.

If it is removed, whats stopping them from dumping on the cartesi token and move into other tokens that allows staking?

2. In a bid to keep the total supply of the $CTSI token at 1B is justified so that new tokens don’t get created and devalue already existing ones because of excess supply and reduced demand.

in this scenario, ending it makes absolute sense.

here’s a middle ground in my opinion.

instead of going with one and neglecting the other, why not make a compromise?

1. Set the total supply to 1b which means no more tokens will get added to the current supply to stabilise market conditions.

2. from the already set 1b supply, lock/vest a certain amount over a designated period of time so that there won’t be a huge amount of supply and when it balances out, demand will outperform the supply which then means an increase in token price which makes holders happy.

3. in the locked supply, there should be a portion allocated SOLELY for stakers and those that want to perform defi activities like borrowing, lending, staking, etc.

this gives the token more utility and has more need to be used by users who holds the token and defi explorers.

This way, there won’t be new token mints and yield can still be earned.

maybe between 2.5 - 3.5% per annum or more, depending on the tokenomics.

2 Likes

Thank you for the transparency in laying out both the Mine Reserve timeline and the MinterRole renunciation proposal. As a long-term holder and substantial pool delegator, I fully support Part 2: permanently burning the MinterRole and enforcing a strict 1B hard cap is the right step to eliminate perpetual dilution and smart-contract minting risk.

​However, because this transition marks the end of the Noether PoS era in ~9–10 months, I would appreciate direct clarification from the Foundation and core contributors on four strategic and operational questions that affect every long-term holder and staker:

​Connecting the 25% Knoss Net Revenue & Future CTSI Tokenomics:

In “The Next Stage for Cartesi,” the Foundation disclosed a contractual right to 25% of Knoss’s net revenue after operating costs, while noting that this economic relationship is currently between Knoss and the Foundation and that CTSI’s economic evolution will be considered separately. Once inflationary staking ends in July 2027, what mechanisms are being explored to bridge commercial ecosystem revenue back to CTSI holders? Are options such as protocol-level fee sharing, buybacks, or CTSI staking/collateral utility within Knoss on the table?

​CTSI Utility in Dave PRT & Sling Validators:

With Dave (PRT) and the Sling validator node moving out of alpha, how does the team envision CTSI fitting into the security and validation layer of Cartesi Rollups and appchains? Will PRT validators or future sequencer/liquidity networks require CTSI bonding or delegation, or will rollup dispute bonds remain strictly ETH-denominated?

​Timeline for Token Economic Updates (Preventing the July 2027 “Unstaking Cliff”):

When the Mine Reserve depletes around July 2027, over 100M+ CTSI currently locked in Noether pools will go from earning ~20% APY to 0% overnight. If there is a gap between the end of Mine Reserve rewards and the introduction of new CTSI utility, the ecosystem risks significant capital flight and sell pressure. Does the Foundation plan to open governance discussions on CTSI’s next-stage utility well ahead of July 2027 (e.g., Q1/Q2 2027) so delegators have a clear transition path before rewards hit zero?

​Reducing L1 Friction for Pool Delegators at Sunset:

Part 1 notes that once pool operators shut down nodes after rewards end, delegators may need to manually trigger pool rebalancing before unstaking and withdrawing. Requiring delegators to pay for three separate Ethereum L1 transactions (rebalance + unstake + withdraw after the 48h lock) adds unnecessary friction. Can the Foundation coordinate with major pool operators to ensure pools are properly balanced before shutdown, or update the Cartesi Explorer UI to streamline this exit process for delegators?

​Looking forward to your thoughts on how we bridge the gap between capping the supply today and capturing real ecosystem value in 2027.

4 Likes

If you truly believe in the project and don’t want your assets to sit idle - best to add it to liquidity pools, though yes - the cartesi team can offer boosted liquidity rewards for that for an initial push

Over time, I have watched the team make impressive decisions and this is one amongst many.

1 Like

Thank you for sharing your thoughts and suggestions. Continuing rewards without minting new CTSI would still require an available funding source. The Foundation’s treasury is needed to support operations and continued development, so we are not planning to allocate treasury tokens to extend Mine Reserve rewards.

Thanks for the thoughtful questions. They touch on important aspects of Cartesi’s direction, and we’d like to provide more context from the Foundation’s perspective:

1. Knoss revenue and CTSI economics

As explained in the blog post The Next Stage for Cartesi, the Foundation’s agreement with Knoss establishes a source of recurring revenue to support continued infrastructure development and business development activities, subject to Knoss’s commercial success.

This economic arrangement is between Knoss and the Foundation. There is no mechanism in the protocol design for distributing revenue to CTSI holders, and the Foundation is not pursuing CTSI buybacks or revenue-sharing programs.

Our priority is to establish a sustainable model for developing Cartesi’s technology, supported by real commercial adoption instead of continued reliance on treasury reserves.

2. CTSI utility and validation infrastructure

We recognize the interest in expanding CTSI’s utility. Our development priorities are guided by what advances Cartesi’s technology and strengthens its infrastructure. Any role for CTSI in validator services, sequencing, or other infrastructure functions should address a genuine need.

Requiring CTSI for services used by Knoss alone would add complexity without necessarily improving the product or underlying infrastructure. Such mechanisms would need to serve a practical purpose supported by real demand across applications beyond Knoss, rather than being introduced ahead of that demand.

Cartesi’s current fraud-proof architecture relies on permissionless validation and ETH-denominated dispute bonds, independently of CTSI staking. There are no current plans to introduce CTSI bonding requirements into Dave or Sling.

The previously approved Validator Marketplace has not entered development and has no announced implementation timeline. Further consideration will depend on ecosystem growth and clear demand for a marketplace.

3. Mine Reserve completion and future incentives

We understand the concern about whether delegators will have clarity on future incentives before Mine Reserve rewards end. We have not scheduled a governance discussion and are not planning a replacement incentive program to coincide with depletion.

The Mine Reserve is an existing, finite allocation, projected to be depleted around July 2027. Its completion does not itself change the current governance voting arrangements. Meaningful participation by CTSI holders remains a priority, and we remain open to a separate discussion or proposal on the role of staking in governance after rewards end.

Our focus is on strengthening the technology and demonstrating its capabilities through real applications. We believe this is where our development efforts can have the greatest practical impact at Cartesi’s current stage.

4. Staking withdrawals and pool operations

The end of rewards does not alter existing staking and withdrawal rights or procedures. Delegators will retain the ability to withdraw their CTSI, although they may need to initiate pool rebalancing where necessary.

Your suggestion to coordinate with pool operators and improve withdrawal guidance is valuable. We will share this with the relevant team for evaluation as the reserve approaches depletion.

It seems my main thoughts have already been posted by someone else further up and there has already been a reply to that from the Cartesi team.

I would always choose the Cartesi tech succeeding over the price of the ctsi token, having a fixed supply makes sense if staking is coming to an end.

I have tweeted many times about the need for a “killer app” - I hope Knoss is exactly that and it appears supporting Knoss is top priority.

I’ve read the team’s reply above - I read it as there is no mechanism for distributing revenue to CTSI holders, no buybacks planned, and no current plans for CTSI in Validator Marketplace, Dave, or Sling, and no replacement incentive program planned for when the Mine Reserve ends.

I’m still leaning to vote YES on renouncing the MinterRole because I support the tech and fixed supply. My question is: does this leave CTSI to end up as a governance-only token after July 2027?

1 Like

Thank you for your continued support. The ecosystem’s commitment to developing Cartesi and supporting Knoss reflects exactly that sentiment about putting the technology first.

Your summary of the current position is accurate: governance is CTSI’s primary function today and would remain its role after Mine Reserve rewards end.

Renouncing the MinterRole would remove minting authority under the existing contract, preventing further issuance and eliminating any risks associated with retaining that authority, without permanently limiting CTSI to governance-only utility.